Seattle appeals ‘outlier’ $30M jury verdict in deadly CHOP shooting

The City of Seattle has appealed the “outlier” $30 million jury verdict in the 2020 deadly shooting of Antonio Mays, Jr. at CHOP, arguing the teen was unlikely to have survived even if medics had reached him minutes sooner.

Earlier this month, the city filed its case in the Washington Court of Appeals seeking to overturn the $30.58 million jury verdict awarded to the Mays family.

In its appeal, the city argues the court committed major errors that warrant dismissal in the case or granting a new trial.

In its filing, Seattle contends the plaintiffs failed to prove the city’s alleged three-to-four-minute delay in medical care caused Mays’ death. Under Washington law, plaintiffs must show it was “more likely than not” — greater than 50% odds — that he would have survived. Medical experts testified Mays had at most a 5% to 10% chance of surviving his eight gunshot wounds even with immediate treatment.

The city also argues a misleading verdict form forced the jury to hold Seattle financially responsible for the unknown shooter’s acts, rather than segregating damages or apportioning fault to people in the camp.

The deadly shooting — one of two killings of Black teens in the camp — came early on a Monday morning amid a night of drive-by shooting fears around the protest zone. Mays was shot inside a stolen Jeep Cherokee that had been reported driving at high speeds through the streets around the CHOP camp. The teen died as camp security and medic volunteers worked to save him while Seattle Police and Seattle Fire refused to enter the protest area.

Mays’s 14-year-old companion in the vehicle survived but suffered a brain injury.

The shooting was a final straw as Seattle Police were ordered to storm the protest encampments and clear the area two days later.

Seattle is also challenging a jury instruction that directed a verdict of negligence for Seattle Fire units failing to meet at a disputed rendezvous site, preventing medics from arguing they reasonably avoided a transport vehicle carrying an armed man on its roof.

Evidence presented during the trial by the Oshan & Associates law firm representing the family revealed new details of the confusion within the camp on the deadly night and how SPD failed to enter the zone until hours after the shooting. That evidence helped foil a city defense that Mays was committing a felony crime at the time of his slaying.

The $30.58 million verdict brought the total damages against the city across major CHOP lawsuits to $44.1 million.

In March, the city said it was planning to seek a new trial — or appeal the verdict.

Similar lawsuits were settled by the city before trials began. In 2022, the city agreed on a $500,000 settlement in the suit brought by Oshan & Associates over the death in the shooting of 19-year-old Lorenzo Anderson on the edge of CHOP. In 2023, it reached a $3.6 million accord with businesses and property owners over the protest zone. Last year, the city settled its largest CHOP case so far as it reached a $10 million settlement with 50 plaintiffs harmed by the SPD’s flawed response to the 2020 Black Lives Matter and CHOP protests.

Evan Oshan of Oshan & Associates, the lawyer representing the Mays family, was also preparing a case for Robert West who was 14 at the time he suffered injuries that left him permanently disabled in the same CHOP shooting.

Since the verdict, new information has been unearthed about the deady night at CHOP including an account from a previously unknown witness and video evidence that marks the killing as an execution-style shooting after a night of drive-by panic around the protest zone.

No suspects in the June 29th, 2020 killing have been publicly identified. SPD says the investigation of the Mays Jr. killing remains an open case.

 
$5 A MONTH TO HELP KEEP CHS PAYWALL-FREE

Subscribe to CHS to help hire writers and photographers to cover the neighborhood. CHS is a pay what you can community news site with no required sign-in or paywall. To stay that way, we need you. Become a subscriber to help us cover the neighborhood for $5 a month — or choose your level of support

 
Exit mobile version