By Tracy Record
West Seattle Blog editor
Almost exactly two years ago – in mid-November 2024 – Seattle Public Schools officials were at Sanislo Elementary, answering families’ questions about the then-proposal to close it and “merge” it into Highland Park Elementary.
Flash forward to mid-November 2026: District officials were at Highland Park Elementary last night, answering families’ questions about a new proposal to close Sanislo and “merge” it into Highland Park.
What’s changed? The district’s financial picture is still dire. Enrollment at the two schools still totals about 460 (in November 2024, it was Sanislo 153 and HP 306; now it’s 124 and 339, according to the district’s monthly enrollment report). But a different superintendent is at the helm: While then-superintendent Dr. Brent Jones was out sick the night of the aforementioned 2024 meeting, Ben Shuldiner – still in his first year leading SPS – was front-and-center last night at HPE.
Families got first word of the new school-closure/merger proposals via e-mail three and a half weeks ago. But Shuldiner said at last night’s meeting that internal discussions started in September, right after the new teachers’ contract was finalized: “We couldn’t start these conversations until we had the union contract.”
Before Q&A, Shuldiner recapped his rationale for mergers – building condition, enrollment total that left some grade classes as “singletons” – the only class for that grade at that school, staffs with “partial FTEs” in some important positions, and limits on the type of special-education services that a school could provide. He said they looked around at the district’s 100+ schools and found 10 that were candidates for mergers.
Originally, Shuldiner said, they evaluated whether Sanislo could be merged into Louia Boren STEM K-8, but given the mismatch in grade levels, he said Highland Park seemed more appropriate.
Next, he said, they met with principals, then other staff. More issues arose from those meetings, he continued, which led to “more changes” in the plan.
Now, at what he described as “sort of the middle” of the process, they’re “having another 11 meetings, with families.” The timeline he outlined from here:
November-December, meet with families. Then he has “to write a letter to the board,” sending them his initial official list of schools proposed for mergers. Another round of meetings will follow, this time “with the community,” and official hearings, in January-February. “Once all of that is done,” one more meeting- a board meeting where the board will make its decision on whether to go along with the recommendation.
For families worried about wanting to choose their child(ren)’s school based on the outcome, he promised that open enrollment would continue post-decision “for at least one more week, with impacted students having dibs.”
He also said families might be concerned about staff (which the subsequent Q&A confirmed they were) – “Nobody is losing their job,” he promised. “Every single person who works at the two schools will still be employed.” He said attrition in the district meant “there’ll always be places.” Also, not everyone might opt to come over. Shuldiner said they’d also be working on formulas that will make sure staffing is correct.
The last major topic his introduction addressed – what would happen to Sanislo’s building?
“As long as I am superintendent, we are not selling anything,” Shuldiner declared. “Once you sell something, you never get it back.” He said they’re already discussing potential alternative uses with “partners” and suggested Sanislo could be used as a “satellite library,” community center, or other possibilities.
“I can’t say we know exactly what’s going to happen, but we’re trying to think deeply about what happens in the long run …” Ultimately, he said the result of a merger could be “something super-special.”
An hour-plus of Q&A followed.
The first questioner wondered if the commitment to no jobs lost meant at the merged school or district wide. How could you have two principals? Shuldiner said they would be OK with extra staff in the beginning but “then if people leave,” they wouldn’t necessarily fill the job.
This led to disclosure of a key point: First year, Highland Park’s Mary McDaniel and Sanislo’s Erika Ayer would be co-principals. After that, the most senior principal would stay. The other principal would have a place to go somewhere else in the district – “we have 106 schools.” The contract is what would require seniority to be considered for leadership, he initially said, though the second questioner countered that. Ultimately, Shuldiner said, they hadn’t quite worked out how the long-term leadership decision would be made. The superintendent said “past practice” might have to be taken into consideration. The parent who asked the question noted that beyond seniority, “There might be some intangible qualities” that families might want to consider.
A Highland Park parent said that parents “want to keep our staff together” and wondered if all the principals really agreed to this being the best scenario for a merger, knowing the HP principal might be the one having to leave in the second year. So what’s the benefit for our staff and our students? the parent asked. Shuldiner said that they decided HP was a better place to move Sanislo than Boren – K-5 as compared to K-8 – but the parent said that justification didn’t seem to fall under the criteria that he had laid out.
Another HP parent voiced support for principal McDaniel and then asked about staff numbers. They might have to add classrooms, she said; the superintendent said they’d done work on that. The parent also asked about counseling resources. Shuldiner had a formula for that – saying they could wind up with a FTE. And he said again that the decision on principal leadership after the first year could change.
A Sanislo parent spoke next. She said that she was concerned about the lack of multiple scenarios from which to choose, that they were only being told one possibility is under consideration. She said for West Seattle, attendance zone issues were a concern; so was a shortage of dual-language programs. “Why are we not looking at A vs. B – it’s way too soon for a school board vote”- she wants to see more explanation of why this was optimal.
“I’ve gotta play the hand that’s dealt to me,” Shuldiner replied, saying he’s working to make sure “each child gets the best posible education …” And as to “why are we doing this now?” he explained bluntly, “Because now is what we have.” Sure, things could better, he acknowledged – “Let’s say we do this amazing job, and the district starts turning around,” maybe in a few years they’d be able to add programming – but he’s dealing with “the reality we have today.”
The parent said she’s just not convinced that the rationale for a merger is there, and noted that this area of West Seattle has been shortchanged on funding time and again.
Next parent at the mic said they needed to elevate the voices of Sanislo teachers. She recalled the closure plan a few years ago, and families fighting for them – “as a community if we’re saying keep Sanislo open, how are we advocating for their needs,” and if they’re voicing support for a merger, how will they hold the district accountable?
The superintendent said he’d love to hear “what more support looks like.” He noted that the Legislature is about to go into session. The funding they’re getting “is not enough.”
A Sanislo parent noted it’s the second attempt to close that school in two years, and “I want to go to a small neighborhood school …in Seattle we crave small walkable community hubs.” She said she doesn’t feel there’s a choice, with one plan placed on the table. Why “as a new leader” has Shuldiner returned to a plan that “the city rejected” two years ago? (The School Board canceled the closure plan two weeks after the 2024 Sanislo meeting we mentioned above.) She also noted that the 80 or so people in the room last night are not representative of everyone from both schools,” suggesting not enough was done to bring others into the discussion.
Shuldiner noted that the final decision is not in his hands – “I have zero power.” He reiterated that this is “meeting number 25 out of 47,” while the parent said, “For many people here, it’s (the first).” She also asked why this district isn’t suing the state like other districts; he said those other districts have some things involved that SPS does not but if they win, it’s good news. The parent countered that it’s important to look at historical reasons why Sanislo is under-enrolled – “our enrollment has been strangled by the district,” with past problems including transportation cuts in the 2010s. He said “I can’t do anything about fixing the past. … We’re trying to figure out if we can get all our 50,000 kids into” a school that’s best for them.
Next at the mic was another Sanislo parent. “A lot of our families are very poor” and the closure could pose a hardship in getting to their child(ren)’s school. She doesn’t drive; getting to the school from her house would be a half-hour ride. A newer building isn’t necessarily better; ‘this is a business model’ and she suggested increasing the student population at HPE would be “an imposition” for the students there.
A Highland Park parent spoke of the “strong” culture built at the school by its staff. The larger class sizes could be problematic. Shuldiner said that can be addressed. “With mergers you actually can see an average class size,”he said. Today’s conditions might lead to a 21-student class size on average, but, he said, it’s possible that might change. Might they lose some of their teachers? the parent asked. They also said “this merger feels incredibly fast.”
The superintendent continued to contend that what’s being proposed is a merger, not a closure, and that it was different from what was planned in 2024 (though our archives suggest the plan, and terminology, was pretty much the same).
Another parent thanked the superintendent for “doing a hard thing”; he wanted an explanation on the staffing results. He explained how the formula would work out – for example, even if a merged school might merit a .5 art teacher, and each current school has a .5 already, theyll both still go to the merged school. The parent also reiterated support for principal McDaniel. He wondered if there are some “other things the district might look at” regarding the ultimate principal decision after year 1. Shuldiner promised “conversations.”
With a potential post-merger student count well above what the questioner called “HPE’s operational capacity of 340” – would HP lose any of its programs? Would the building be pushed beyond its capacity? Also, she said, the idea of options for Sanislo building’s future is nice but “(the ex-elementary school) Roxhill is rotting away.” What about “developmental preschool”? the parent reiterated. “Preschool is a very different piece of this,” Shuldiner replied, but overall, the district is looking at where preschool might belong – especially when it doesn’t feed into the rest of the school. He said he couldn’t speak about where preK fits in with the district; “you ARE the district,” the parent retorted.
An HP parent who is also a teacher asked the question about why the term merger is being used when it’s a closure – Sanislo would close. The superintendent reiterated that because they’re moving everyone into a new school, it’s a merger. “For the first year,” the parent/teacher replied. They also had other questions about allocation, especially considering both schools’ Title I status.
The next person at the mic carried on with that line of questioning and how per-student funding would be allocated. He also was concerned about resources, and about losing a principal after the first year. “It feels like this is an exercise in trust …. but it feels like it’s going to be difficult for both (schools).” Sanislo had gotten the short end of the stick so many times that “there feels like there’s no reason to be doing this – I don’t see the urgency and the need.” The superintendent insisted it would mean more resources for Sanislo; the questioner disagreed. “You want us to trust you that you’re going to resource kids better.”
“I’m not even asking you to trust me,” said Shuldiner. He said they believe they could successfully move Sanislo to this building. “trying to get our kids into the best (situation) as quickly as possible.”
Another HP family member noted that they’d come from Concord International Elementary in South Park – and observed that school communities are different, even if they look similar on paper. How will they make sure that the social-emotional aspect of the merger is handled well? Shuldiner said that he hadn’t meant to suggest that Sanislo and HP kids are the same. He said they’re working on a team of social workers and others to help if needed. “They’re not just going to help the students, but the adults too,” he said, acknowledging it’s a potentially “traumatic” situation. The family member said social-economic upheaval can take away from educational matters for the staff too, and Shuldiner assured them that the special team would be available to help the staff too. The person at the mic said it’s not so easy to ignore what’s happened in the past, so please take that into consideration when going forward.
The superintendent clarified, “I didn’t say the past is irrelevant (but that) I can’t change it.”
The meeting had already gone overtime by then, but several people remained in line for the microphone. An HP parent who had been a Sanislo parent said he feels “very vested in both communities” and said he supports the merger as “an opportunity to give Sanislo kids the best foot forward.” He said expectations at Sanislo had been low. He said it’s important to hold students to high expectations and so it would be important to make this “successful for everyone.” He said “this ultimately … should be about improving the educational opportunity. …. what’s best for our children …”
At quarter till 8, 15 minutes after the announced end, Shuldiner said they had to wrap up but promised that he would stay as long as needed for one-on-one conversations.
No date was announced for another meeting, but we should note that Superintendent Shuldiner is on a “community engagement” tour; the next event is an online meeting tonight (Tuesday, November 17, 6:30 pm); his next in-person meeting is in West Seattle, 6:30 pm Tuesday, December 15, at the Denny/Sealth campus (2600 SW Thistle).
EDITOR’S NOTE: We learned about this meeting – as we had of the one at Sanislo two years ago – from affected schools’ family members forwarding district messages. They asked us to cover the meeting, and we told them we were planning on it. After we arrived and sat down on the side of the room, we were told by a district official that the meeting was not open to the media and that we needed to leave. We refused. In his opening remarks, the superintendent subsequently warned those in attendance that your editor was there (without naming me; I raised my hand high so everyone could see) and reiterated that I had been asked to leave. Several people vocally objected (thank you). The superintendent went on to say our presence made the meeting “unsafe” for families. We don’t know what that was supposed to mean, as no sensitive or personal information was requested or offered; as a journalist since age 17, I deeply believe that to the contrary, in a situation like this where elected officials are going to make an impactful decision involving public money, public land, and community members, more information being available – responsibly, accurately, and impartially reported – to more people sooner is actually a “safer” and better thing.